| Date | Opponent | Location | Time/Score |
| 2.22.2012 | Bandeis | Winter Haven, Florida (Lake Myrtle #3) |
W (12 - 0) |
| 2.22.2012 | Brandeis | Winter Haven, Florida |
L (1 - 3) |
| 2.23.2012 | Brandeis | Winter Haven, Florida (Chain of Lakes Stadium) |
W (16 - 2) |
| 2.25.2012 | Franklin | Winter Haven, Florida (Lake Myrtle Park #2) |
L (4 - 12) |
| 2.27.2012 | Milwaukee School of Engineering | Winter Haven, Florida (Chain of Lakes #1) |
W (4 - 2) |
| 2.28.2012 | Rose-Hulman | Winter Haven, Florida (Lake Myrtle Park #1) |
W (10 - 8) |
| 2.29.2012 | Loras | Winter Haven, Florida (Lake Myrtle Park #2) |
W (9 - 5) |
| 2.29.2012 | Loras | Winter Haven, Florida |
W (3 - 1) |
| 3.1.2012 | Wartburg | Winter Haven, Florida (Chain of Lakes #1) |
W (3 - 2) |
| 3.16.2012 | Minnesota-Morris | Fort Myers, Florida (Red Sox Player Development Complex #2) |
W (6 - 1) |
| 3.16.2012 | Minnesota-Morris | Ft. Myers, Florida (Red Sox Player Development Center) |
W (20 - 0) |
| 3.17.2012 | Wisconsin-Lutheran | Fort Myers, Florida (Red Sox Player Development Center @3) |
W (16 - 6) |
| 3.18.2012 | Olivet | Fort Myers, Florida (Terry Park #1) |
W (5 - 0) |
| 3.25.2012 | Aurora | HOME |
L (1 - 2) |
| 3.28.2012 | Monmouth | HOME |
W (8 - 3) |
| 3.31.2012 | *Elmhurst | Elmhurst, Illinois |
L (2 - 5) |
| 3.31.2012 | Elmhurst | Elmhurst, Ill. |
W (4 - 2) |
| 4.1.2012 | *Elmhurst | HOME |
L (5 - 11) |
| 4.3.2012 | *North Central | HOME |
L (8 - 9) |
| 4.3.2012 | *North Central | HOME |
L (4 - 5) |
| 4.6.2012 | *Carthage | Kenosha, Wisconsin |
W (2 - 1) |
| 4.6.2012 | *Carthage | Kenosha, Wisconsin |
w (9 - 3) |
| 4.7.2012 | *Carthage | Kenosha, Wisconsin |
L (7 - 10) |
| 4.11.2012 | *North Central | Naperville, Illinois |
W (5 - 3) |
| 4.14.2012 | *North Park | HOME |
W (12 - 5) |
| 4.14.2012 | *North Park | Home |
L (5 - 9) |
| 4.15.2012 | *North Park | HOME |
W (13 - 3) |
| 4.17.2012 | Loras | HOME |
L (1 - 2) |
| 4.18.2012 | Knox | HOME |
W (7 - 2) |
| 4.20.2012 | *Wheaton | HOME |
W (1 - 0) |
| 4.21.2012 | *Wheaton | Wheaton, Illinois |
L (0 - 8) |
| 4.21.2012 | *Wheaton | Wheaton, Illinois |
W (3 - 1) |
| 4.25.2012 | Grinnell | HOME |
W (11 - 4) |
| 4.27.2012 | *Illinois Wesleyan | HOME |
L (1 - 3) |
| 4.28.2012 | *Illinois Wesleyan | Bloomington, Illinois |
W (9 - 5) |
| 4.28.2012 | *Illinois Wesleyan | Bloomington, Ill. |
W (4 - 3) |
| 5.1.2012 | Dubuque | HOME |
L (9 - 10) |
| 5.5.2012 | *Millikin | HOME |
W (5 - 2) |
| 5.5.2012 | *Millikin | HOME |
L (5 - 12) |
| 5.6.2012 | *Millikin (single) | HOME |
L (1 - 8) |
| 5.10.2012 | CCIW Tournament vs. North Park | Chicago, Illinois |
L (3 - 4) |
| 5.11.2012 | CCIW Tournament vs. Elmhurst | Chicago, Illinois (North Park) |
L (6 - 7) |
