| Date | Opponent | Location | Time/Score |
| 9.1.2009 | Chicago | Chicago, Illinois |
L (1 - 2) |
| 9.4.2009 | Lake Forest | Lake Forest, Illinois |
W (3 - 1) |
| 9.8.2009 | Greenville | HOME |
W(1 - 0) |
| 9.12.2009 | Grinnell (@ UW-Oshkosh Tournament) | Oshkosh, Wisconsin |
L (0 - 1) |
| 9.13.2009 | Hamline (@ UW-Oshkosh Tournament) | Oshkosh, Wisconsin |
L (1 - 2) |
| 9.19.2009 | *Carthage | HOME |
W (2 - 1) |
| 9.23.2009 | Loras | Dubuque, Iowa |
L (0 - 3) |
| 9.26.2009 | *Elmhurst | Elmhurst, Illinois |
L (3 - 4) |
| 9.29.2009 | Coe | HOME |
L (0 - 1) |
| 10.7.2009 | *Wheaton | Wheaton, Illinois |
W (1 - 0) |
| 10.10.2009 | *North Park | HOME |
W (2 - 0) |
| 10.13.2009 | Beloit | Beloit, Wisconsin |
T (0 - 0) |
| 10.17.2009 | *North Central | HOME |
L (1 - 2) |
| 10.21.2009 | Knox | Galesburg, Illinois |
W (4 - 2) |
| 10.24.2009 | *Illinois Wesleyan | HOME |
T (1 - 1) |
| 10.27.2009 | Central of Iowa | Pella, Iowa |
L (1 - 3) |
| 10.29.2009 | Aurora | HOME |
L (1 - 2) |
| 11.1.2009 | *Millikin | Decatur, Illinois |
T (1 - 1) |
| 11.4.2009 | CCIW Tournament vs. Elmhurst | Elmhurst, Illinois |
L (0 - 2) |
